Are Temperament Tests Good for Dogs?

In the world of dog adoption, temperament tests are king. These all important tests are widely used by animal shelters and rescues to understand more about the dogs in their care. Better yet, they help shelter staff to find the best adoptive home for dogs based on the information they gather from temperament tests. Thought this has been an effective way to gather information in the past, experts are calling them into question now and wondering if there isn’t a better way to assess dogs going forward.

One of the most commonly used and known tests is the food bowl test. Dogs are given a meal in a bowl, and then a tester tries to remove food from the dog and from the bowl to see if the animal has a reaction. This is known as guarding resource behavior and in some cases, can be dangerous for homes that have small children that could accidentally reach into a dog’s food bowl. The downside of such a test is that an animal could be euthanized if they fail, because it could be too dangerous to place that dog with a family.

NPR//Facebook

The other danger of this particular type of test is that it creates a singular view. A dog with food based aggression could be an otherwise wonderful animal that can be trusted around children. There are many other factors to consider when evaluating if a dog has problems that should be addressed before or after it is adopted into a new home. The test is simply an indicator of a potential issue.

Experts agree that temperament tests are a great way to gather information about a dog before placing it in a home, but further testing should be done to ensure staff gets a better handle on a dog before choosing adoption or euthanasia.

Next Article
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Puppy Mill Dog has New Life as a Therapy Dog

    A sweet dog named Rolo was rescued from a truly terrible situation in 2013. He and several other young puppies were removed by the RSPCA from a “puppy farm.” This was a last ditch effort to save the lives of these young dogs and many rescuers were not sure if...

    Read More
  • Man Known as “Responsible Breeder” was Hiding a Secret

    As many animal lovers know, there are many people out there who are bad breeders. These are people who run facilities that are not kept clean and do not treat dogs with respect. They are simply a facility to quickly breed dogs by any means necessary to make money. It...

    Read More
  • Shelter Finds Unique Way to Comfort Scared Dogs

    For many dogs, bath time is perhaps one of the scariest times in their lives or at least their monthly routine. Some dogs may enjoy the experience of bathing, while so many others find it to be a scary, traumatizing experience. For one dog named Epic, taking a bath is just that: terrifying and possibly...

    Read More
  • Dog Walks 4 Blocks to Play with his Friend

    Jenna Termolen and her family had made up their mind: they wanted to adopt a female dog. They set up meetings with several potential girl dogs to visit, but in the meantime they met a male dog named Tommy. It was love and first sight for everyone, including Tommy, who had to be drug out...

    Read More
  • Why Do Dogs Sneeze “Backwards?”

    Every dog owner has been there: your dog sneezes, but it sounds and looks like it is happening in reverse. It might sound like they are choking or even as though they have a cold, but they really are just sneezing. Have you ever seen this in your dog? Typically, a dog will stand very...

    Read More
  • Dog Thinks his Toys Make the Best Bed

    Back when a dog named Nugget was just a little pup, he was hit by a car. This trauma left him quite injured and his owners felt they were unable to take care of him. So, little Nugget the dog was surrendered to an animal shelter by his family....

    Read More
  • Blind Puppy Finds Comfort in His New Sister

    For a miniature Australian shepherd dog named Dunder, she has never known what it is like to enjoy a sunny day or a run in the park. You see, Dunder was born blind and when the breeder who owned her realized this she knew she had to find a special home for the young pooch....

    Read More