Are Temperament Tests Good for Dogs?

In the world of dog adoption, temperament tests are king. These all important tests are widely used by animal shelters and rescues to understand more about the dogs in their care. Better yet, they help shelter staff to find the best adoptive home for dogs based on the information they gather from temperament tests. Thought this has been an effective way to gather information in the past, experts are calling them into question now and wondering if there isn’t a better way to assess dogs going forward.

One of the most commonly used and known tests is the food bowl test. Dogs are given a meal in a bowl, and then a tester tries to remove food from the dog and from the bowl to see if the animal has a reaction. This is known as guarding resource behavior and in some cases, can be dangerous for homes that have small children that could accidentally reach into a dog’s food bowl. The downside of such a test is that an animal could be euthanized if they fail, because it could be too dangerous to place that dog with a family.


The other danger of this particular type of test is that it creates a singular view. A dog with food based aggression could be an otherwise wonderful animal that can be trusted around children. There are many other factors to consider when evaluating if a dog has problems that should be addressed before or after it is adopted into a new home. The test is simply an indicator of a potential issue.

Experts agree that temperament tests are a great way to gather information about a dog before placing it in a home, but further testing should be done to ensure staff gets a better handle on a dog before choosing adoption or euthanasia.

Next Article
  • Man Finds Dog in Basement of his New Home

    A unique phone call came in to the offices of the Stray Rescue of St. Louis organization recently. It was a man who recently purchased a new home and found something unbelievable in the basement: a pit bull chained to the wall. It was unclear how long the dog had been down in the basement...

    Read More
  • Sick, Tiny Puppy Rescued by Woman

    Marcela Wedel was not interested in adopting another dog into her home. With four rescue dogs already, it was safe to say she had a full house already. However, when she watched a dog named Maia, who had been rescued from a terrible situation, give birth to puppies, she had a change of heart. Marcela...

    Read More
  • Runners find Puppies on Wooded Trail

    Ashley Blake and Joshua Scott are no strangers to the Barkley Marathons course, a strenuous 50 kilometer race that snakes through Frozen Head State Park in Wartburg, Tennessee. The pair was trekking through the woods in preparation for the race when they heard some loud rustling near the trail. This did not come as a...

    Read More
  • Dog Living in Garbage has Great Life Now

    Sophie had been living on the streets for quite a while, but no one knows exactly how long. Based on her condition and her overall disposition, it was clearly for far too long. She was found in February on the streets of Tijuana, Mexico laying on top of a pile of rotten garbage. Sophie was...

    Read More
  • Women Gets Letter from Deceased Dog

    As anyone who owns and loves a dog knows, they are a truly valuable member of the family. They live alongside their owners for decades or more and letting them go is a difficult, sad situation when the day comes. A woman named Ashley Bowerman knows this all too well, as she shared in a...

    Read More
  • Man Returns to Shelter to Rescue His Dog

    The animal shelter is full of dogs with a past. Many are dogs that are found wandering the street while still others were given up by their families for one reason or another. For a dog named Titus, the latter was true: his owner, a man named Lewis Jimenez had no choice but to give...

    Read More
  • Family Dog Accidentally Flown to Japan

    The friendly skies are not always so friendly for those of us who try to fly with our dogs. United Airlines is facing backlash after they made a major error in flying one family’s dog to the wrong destination. By wrong destination, that does not mean the wrote state. The airline actually flew a puppy...

    Read More