Do People Care More About Dog Suffering than Humans?

April Livingston | November 9th, 2017

For so many people, dogs are more than just animals: they are valued members of the family. But for many people, there is more of sympathy toward dogs than there is for a fellow human. Which really begs an important question; do people love dogs more than they love their people? This is what researchers set out to answer in a recent study that looked at the sympathy humans have for dogs versus the sympathy they feel for human beings.

The study was held by the Northeastern University in Boston, Massachusetts and by the University of Colorado in Boulder, Colorado. What they discovered was that people actually do have stronger feelings for dogs than people. The study, which was recently published in a journal called Society and Animals, surveyed approximately 256 undergraduate students. The students were shown fake news stories that contained police reports about either a puppy, dog, human, infant, child, human, or human adult that had been brutally beaten.  

Barkpost//Facebook

There were a number of experiments held, but one of them was where students read reports about a victim, left unconscious with a broken leg and multiple lacerations after being attacked with a baseball bat by an unknown assailant. The victim varied, from a baby to an adult to a puppy or an adult dog. Then, students were asked to answer a series of questions in order to measure empathy. The results showed that people had significantly more sympathy for dogs including puppies and adult dogs. The reason was that they felt humans had the ability to defend themselves, while dogs are defenseless and therefore more worthy of sympathy.

Empathy is a strong emotion and one that we feel for all those who are facing terrible circumstances, but at the end of the day it’s clear that the love humans feel for dogs is very, very strong!

Next Article
ADVERTISEMENT
  • “Bad” Dog Proves Everyone Wrong

    A dog named Duke already had a bad reputation when he was found as a stray in Charlotte, North Carolina. Not only was he wandering near a highway, but he was dirty and he was an American bulldog mix. He was somewhere between one and three years old and he was wild and had a...

    Read More
  • “Walrus Dog” found in Garbage Bag

    It was truly a miracle that the dog was still alive. It was a Shih Tzu and someone had wrapped her in a black garbage bag and dumped her at the Richmond Animal Care and Control (RACC) shelter in Virginia. Aside from the garbage bag, the little dog was in terrible condition. She was missing...

    Read More
  • Dog Chooses Family in the Best Way

    When a woman named Beatriz Baranski Kaniak and her husband moved into their new home in Chile, their four rescue dogs moved in too. They moved in January and had only been in the home a few days when the most amazing thing happened. The family’s front gate was left open most of the day...

    Read More
  • Dog Heals with Help of Cat Friend

    Cats and dogs are not known for their love of one another. But a woman named Shirley recently discovered that the two species in fact can be friends—and successfully change each other’s lives. It all started when she was walking her dog Odie eight years ago and came across a stray kitten. The kitten began...

    Read More
  • Puppies Discovered with Rubber Bands on Mouths

    When a pipe burst in a housing complex in Wichita, Kansas a maintenance worker arrived to fix the problem. However, the moment he entered the apartment in question he realized things were not as they seemed. In fact, things seemed to be quite wrong. When he entered the apartment, there was an awful stench in...

    Read More
  • Dog with “Different” Nose Finds Family

    For a dog named Clefford, things have not been so easy. The sweet dog, who has a cleft palate, recently found himself living on the streets with his family after they became homeless. The family could not care for him and could not afford to get him treatment. So, they made the choice to surrender...

    Read More
  • Man Uses School Bus to Rescue Dogs

    Tony Alsup is a fifty one year old truck driver from Greenback, Tennessee. Ironically, he is also an animal lover who would do anything to help the living creatures he loves so much. While he is a truck driver, he also owns an old school bus and uses it every chance he gets to help...

    Read More
  • Volunteers Line Up for Dogs During Hurricane

    A woman named Ali Standish had agreed to foster a puppy from a local organization as Hurricane Florence headed toward the area. When she arrived at her local shelter, the long was very long and continued to grow as she and many others waited. Each person was there because they had volunteered to take in...

    Read More