Do People Care More About Dog Suffering than Humans?

April Livingston | November 9th, 2017

For so many people, dogs are more than just animals: they are valued members of the family. But for many people, there is more of sympathy toward dogs than there is for a fellow human. Which really begs an important question; do people love dogs more than they love their people? This is what researchers set out to answer in a recent study that looked at the sympathy humans have for dogs versus the sympathy they feel for human beings.

The study was held by the Northeastern University in Boston, Massachusetts and by the University of Colorado in Boulder, Colorado. What they discovered was that people actually do have stronger feelings for dogs than people. The study, which was recently published in a journal called Society and Animals, surveyed approximately 256 undergraduate students. The students were shown fake news stories that contained police reports about either a puppy, dog, human, infant, child, human, or human adult that had been brutally beaten.  

Barkpost//Facebook

There were a number of experiments held, but one of them was where students read reports about a victim, left unconscious with a broken leg and multiple lacerations after being attacked with a baseball bat by an unknown assailant. The victim varied, from a baby to an adult to a puppy or an adult dog. Then, students were asked to answer a series of questions in order to measure empathy. The results showed that people had significantly more sympathy for dogs including puppies and adult dogs. The reason was that they felt humans had the ability to defend themselves, while dogs are defenseless and therefore more worthy of sympathy.

Empathy is a strong emotion and one that we feel for all those who are facing terrible circumstances, but at the end of the day it’s clear that the love humans feel for dogs is very, very strong!

Next Article
ADVERTISEMENT
  • “Mean” Dog at Shelter for 4 Years

    Rose spent most of her life with no one to believe in her. That all changed, however, when a woman named Glorianne Lagnese gave the dog a chance. Glorianne’s friend adopted Rose from a shelter in 2013 and then she took the dog into her own home. Rose had a lot of things going against...

    Read More
  • Missing Dog Found in Weirdest Place

    A dog named Purdy and her family went for their morning walk around 6 a.m. recently. Purdy typically runs around the area with her dog siblings but stays near her human family. But that morning, Purdy heard a loud sound that scared her and she spooked and ran way. It was so foggy that morning...

    Read More
  • Service Dog to President Bush Says Goodbye

    As far as loyalty is concerned, no one on Earth is more loyal than a dog. That is certainly the case for one special dog named Sully. Sully is a service dog that was trained through a nonprofit group known as America’s VetDogs. Sully, who is named after Captain Chesley “Sully” Sullenberger who made an...

    Read More
  • Dog with Head Tilt Gets Help

    Two women who live in Tijuana, Mexico run a temporary spay and neuter clinic in the area. The pair, named Elaine Seamans and Rebeca Altamirano, worked until 10 at night and then got in their cars to get tacos and head home. But as they were driving they realized there were other dogs who needed...

    Read More
  • Dog in Wheelchair Returned Repeatedly

    A dog named Bandit first found himself in the shelter when he was picked up as a stray in Georgia. While has the Gwinnet County Animal Shelter, he was brought into the Gwinnett Jail Dogs Program. However, after being checked by a vet, it was determined Bandit had heartworm. So, he was given treatment to...

    Read More
  • Obese Dog Too Big for Kennel

    When an individual who owned six dogs fell ill, they were no longer able to care for their dogs. So, they asked the Gables Farm Dogs & Cats Home in the UK to take them in. The shelter staff quickly agreed and began to make arrangements to care for all of the dogs. They were...

    Read More
  • Dog Abandoned with Toys and Bed

    When a dog named Wall-E found himself in the Maricopa County Animal Shelter, he was a young dog. He was adopted from the shelter in 2015 and the Labrador Retriever mix had a great life with his new family, including all the toys and treats he could possibly want. Then, the day came that all...

    Read More
  • Sick Stray Dog Loves Toys

    Bella the dog can’t talk, but if she could she’d have quite the tale to tell. Her life clearly hasn’t been easy, based on her condition. The German shepherd was found by a good Samaritan on the side of the highway in Lancaster, Pennsylvania. She was painfully thin and missing most of her fur. The...

    Read More